> Dansk

New study: Anti-bullying programme strengthens children’s empathetic behaviour

Preschool children who engage in the anti-bullying programme Free of Bullying demonstrate empathetic behaviour more overtly than children who are not exposed to the programme.

Children attending institutions that have worked with Free of Bullying are more inclined to express their feelings, actively contribute to developing positive relationships, and show empathy, compared with children in institutions that do not work with the programme. These results are revealed in a new study conducted by Rambøll on behalf on The Mary Foundation and Save the Children Denmark. The effect is statistically significant.

With Free of Bullying, we work systematically to create a tolerant, respectful and compassionate culture among children, and the new study confirms that incorporating Free of Bullying into the preschool’s daily routine makes a significant difference. It simply rubs off on the children’s behaviour in a positive way,” said Director of The Mary Foundation Helle Østergaard.

The study measured the impact among children from 16 preschools. The preschools were divided into a treatment group and a control group. Preschools in the treatment group were given materials and tuition in Free of Bullying and worked with the programme for five months. Teachers in the control group worked with the children as they normally would. A total of 649 children participated in the study.

In both groups, a detailed questionnaire was used to assess the children both prior to and after the study. These questionnaires were completed by the children’s teachers, who responded to a series of questions about the children’s wellbeing and behaviour. The questionnaire covers a range of social characteristics which combine to provide insight into how the child demonstrates empathy and self-regulating behaviour and his or her ability to work with others.

One of the things we looked at as part of the study was the level of empathy demonstrated among the children, because we know from research that children subconsciously disregard their empathy in order to survive socially in groups impacted by extensive bullying. Conversely, children who feel secure in their social environment show more care and respect for other children. That’s why it makes sense specifically to measure empathy in children’s groups,” said Secretary General at Save the Children Denmark, Jonas Keiding Lindholm.

Questions such as “How does it feel not to be allowed to participate in a game?” and “Where can you feel it when you feel sad?” are an integral part of everyday life in preschools that work with the Free of Bullying anti-bullying programme. Taking their daily experiences as their reference point, children and teachers talk about feelings, friendship and the challenges the children face in their social lives. The goal is to help the children feel safe in their school community, so that they can develop an understanding of their own and others’ feelings and needs, and of what it means to be a good friend. And this kind of focused effort works.

The study also indicates that there is a correlation between the extent to which parents are included in the work with Free of Bullying and the benefits gained by the children. Similarly, the extent of the impact resulting from the programme correlates with how intensely the institutions work with Free of Bullying.

Free of Bullying has been evaluated on a regular basis since it was launched in 2007. But this is the first time The Mary Foundation and Save the Children Denmark have studied the quantitative effects of their joint anti-bullying programme in a study using a control group.

Download a summary of the study.

Facts about the study

• The study was conducted between October 2016 and March 2017, in three Danish municipalities: Viborg, Thisted and Odense. Six hundred and forty-nine children distributed among 16 preschools participated in the study.

• Each municipality selected a number of institutions, which were then categorised based on background factors, such as size of institution, official rating and proportion of bilingual children. The institutions were subsequently randomly divided into two groups: a treatment group or a control group.

• The teachers in the treatment group were taught how to work with Free of Bullying and then applied this to their children’s groups over a five-month period, while the control group continued working in their usual way. Both groups completed pre- and post-evaluations of the children’s social-emotional skills based on the validated measurement tool SEAM (Social-Emotional Assessment/Evaluation Measure). The results were then adjusted for other background factors that have the potential to influence children’s social-emotional development.

• The preschools in the control group were also provided with the Free of Bullying materials and instruction in how to use them after the study was completed.

• SEAM has been developed by Professor Jane Squires from Oregon University, which conducts research into early childhood learning.

Source:

Effektevaluering Fri for Mobberi og børns socioemotionelle kompetencer, 2017. (Impact evaluation: Free of Bullying and children’s social-emotional skills, 2017.) Produced by Rambøll for The Mary Foundation and Save the Children Denmark.

Why early intervention is necessary

• Research shows that bullying already starts in preschool (Kit Stender Petersen, Mobning i en børnehavesammenhæng (Bullying in the context of preschool), Roskilde University, 2015).

• While few studies on bullying among preschool children have been conducted in Denmark, Norwegian studies show that 10–20% of all preschool children experience bullying at least once a week (Mai Brit Helgesen, Mobbing i barnehagen (Bullying in kindergarten), Universitetsforlaget, 2014).

• Bullying can occur in all social situations where people are “forced” to spend time together (Helle Rabøl Hansen, Grundbog mod mobning, Gyldendal Uddannelse, 2005).

• The Danish researcher Dorte Marie Søndergaard explains that bullying does not arise as a result of children lacking empathy.

But when groups are affected by bullying, children are not “at liberty” to show empathy towards the child/children who are being subjected to the bullying, because they would then be at risk of being excluded from the group as well. They are perfectly capable of showing empathy towards their family and friends. This phenomenon is called “selective use of empathy” (from the chapter ‘Mobning og social eksklusionsangst’ in the Danish anthology Mobning – Sociale processer på afveje, Hans Reitzels Forlag, 2009).

Når pædagoger, lærere og forældre sammen sætter fokus på det gode børnefællesskab og på at lære børn og unge, at mobning er uacceptabelt, så virker det...
Kronprinsessen hyldede partnerskabet og brede alliancer i arbejdet med at bekæmpe komplekse sociale...
Vores samarbejde med MH24 - Mikkel Mod Mobning har knopskudt, og vi har netop lanceret Antibulli-prisen...
mary_fonden Ensomhed er et stigende problem blandt unge. Det vigtigste, vi kan gøre, er at tale om det, række ud og bryde tabuet. Vi skal forstå ensomhed for at kunne bekæmpe den. Mary Fondens vision er, at alle mennesker skal have adgang til nære og respektfulde relationer, hvor andre er noget for dem, og hvor de kan være noget for andre. #alleharrettilathøretil
mary_fonden Hvordan styrker vi unges sociale trivsel? Vores projekt Me&We handler om at styrke efterskoleelevers sociale kompetencer og relationer. I dag lander dette materialekatalog sammen med vandflasker og kopper på de 31 efterskoler, der er del af næste fase af projektet i det kommende skoleår. Kataloget består af viden og aktiviteter, der skal støtte elevernes forståelse af sig selv og hinanden. Læs mere via link i bio. Me&We er er samarbejde mellem Mary Fonden, @justhuman.dk, @efterskolerne og @tuborgfondet.
mary_fonden Er mobning blevet til isolering af nogle børn? Det spørgsmål stiller mobbeforsker Helle Rabøl Hansen i fagbladet Folkeskolen på baggrund af stigende ensomhed blandt børn og unge. "Nogle børn og unge oplever at være luft for de andre. Derfor vælger de at være tavse i løbet af skoledagen, for det er da bedre end aktivt at blive chikaneret af de andre i klassen. Så kommer lærerne og siger: 'Du byder ikke nok ind i undervisningen' eller 'Du skal ikke være så tilbageholdende'. Men Eva på 13 år har ikke lyst til at byde ind og dermed gøre opmærksom på sig selv. Så er det bedre slet ikke at blive set." Hun opfordrer skolerne til at tænke trivsel og deres indsats mod mobning bredere - og fx medtænke ensomhed i indsatsen. Læs mere i artiklen fra fagbladet Folkeskolen. Link i bio 👆🏼 #alleharrettilathøretil #ensomhed #mobning
mary_fonden Nu begynder forskellige sports og fritidsaktiviteter for børn så småt at starte op igen. Når aktiviteterne begynder igen, er det vigtigt at huske at arbejde for den gode klubkultur. Mary Fondens projekt Antibulli er et antimobberedskab til børnehåndboldtrænere. Det består af konkrete råd og øvelser til træningen af 6-12-årige. Målet er at skabe en hold- og klubkultur med høj tolerance, hvor alle respekterer hinanden, taler ordentligt og hjælper hinanden, så klubben er et rart sted at være, uanset hvor god man er til håndbold. Grundtanken er, at et stærkt sammenhold og gode børnefællesskaber forebygger eksklusion og mobning. Link til Antibulli.dk i bio.
mary_fonden I dag optager vi til en film om noget, der rammer ned i kernen af vores arbejde. At alle har ret til at høre til og føle sig som en del af noget større end sig selv. Det budskab og det arbejde er kun blevet endnu mere aktuelt under Corona-krisen. Stay tuned, når vi offentliggør filmen om nogle uger.